Loading…
← CockpitCompetitor Analysis › AFG American Financial Group, Inc.Open in the cockpit ↗

American Financial Group, Inc.AFGCompetitor analysis, valuation and peers

United States · USD·Financials›Property/Casualty Insurance

Specialty property-casualty insurer focused on niche commercial insurance lines, plus annuity products.

Momentum leader 80
Mkt cap
$13.1B
US dollars, full cap
Free float
83%
of shares outstanding
$/day
$78.1M
20-day average traded
P/B
2.77×
price to book
ROE
21.6%
delivered
Implied ROE
16.1%
what the price asks
Official | Implied
BBB+ / BBB
agencies · bond market
Next earnings
83 days
9 Feb 2027
Close · USD$157.95
1D-0.7%
1W-2.0%
1M+5.8%
3M+9.9%
6M+15.3%
YTD+15.6%
1Y+13.7%
ATR %1.8%
Beta-0.12
52w lowhigh3.3% off high

What American Financial does

Specialty property-casualty insurer focused on niche commercial insurance lines, plus annuity products.

Earns by choosing narrow specialty commercial risks to insure under the Great American Insurance Group name, collecting premiums and investing them until claims are paid. The annuity side earns the gap between what it credits policyholders and what its investments return.

Products and services

  • Specialty commercial property/casualty
  • Annuities

Customers

  • Small/mid-size businesses (niche commercial risks)
  • Annuity policyholders

Where it sits in the supply chain

  • Financials
  • Insurance
  • Specialty commercial P&C and annuities

What could go right

  • Specialty commercial rate hardening
  • Annuity sales growth in a higher-rate environment

What could go wrong

  • Catastrophe exposure in property lines
  • Interest-rate risk on annuity liabilities

Moat: narrow (process know-how). Long-running focus on niche specialty commercial lines where underwriting expertise limits new entrants.

Headquarters: Cincinnati, Ohio, United States · Founded: 1959 · Employees: 8,500

Named competitors

American Financial at a glance

Size American Financial (AFG) is a United States Financials company (Property/Casualty Insurance) with a market value of $13.1B, the 657th largest of 3,085 United States companies the cockpit tracks. Shares closed at $157.95 on 18 Nov 2026.

Performance Over six months the shares gained 15.3%, against +13.5% for the median peer and -2.2% for the United States market (cap-weighted) — 9th highest of 21 in its peer set.

Growth Revenue grew 2.1% over the last twelve months (peer median +3.1%); the operating margin is 14.8% (peer median 14.7%).

Valuation It trades at 2.77× book value against a peer median of 2.02× (7th most expensive of 21).

Price implies The share price implies a return on equity of about 16.1%; American Financial delivers 21.6%, so the price asks less than the business earns today.

Credit American Financial has 3 bonds outstanding ($1.17B), rated BBB+ by the agencies and trading like BBB at a weighted spread of 112 bp.

Short interest Short interest is 2.1% of the free float (30 Oct 2026).

Next results Next results expected around 9 Feb 2027 (exchange calendar; dates can move).

Relative performance

10011021 May 202621 Aug 202618 Nov 2026AFG 115Peer median 115
Six months, rebased to 100: American Financial against the median of its 20 peers (local-currency closes).

American Financial financials

Reported figures in USD; fiscal year ends 2025-12-31. TTM = trailing twelve months.
TTMFY2025FY2024FY2023FY2022
Revenue$8.39B$8.12B$8.28B$7.73B$6.77B
Revenue growth—-2%+7%+14%—
Net income$1.02B$842M$887M$852M$898M
Free cash flow$1.63B$1.40B$1.02B$1.90B$1.07B
Capital expenditure$121M$135M$133M$72.0M$86.0M
Total debt$2.02B$2.04B$1.71B$1.67B$1.61B

Quarterly statements and history in the cockpit →

American Financial competitor charts

The default views of Competitor Analysis ▸ Charts, drawn from the same data. Open them in the cockpit to change the axes, pin companies and read every value.

Performance: 6-month against 1-month return

0%+10%+20%-10%0%+10%ERIERNRIAGEGAIZ000810ADMTHGLMKLSCRQBESIGIDFYSAMPOHGTYMTGHIGMCYARXAFG6-month return →1-month return →
Up and to the right = strong over both horizons. American Financial is the large dot.

Fundamentals: return on equity against price-to-book

5%10%15%20%25%20×40×60×80×ERIERNRIAGEGAIZ000810ADMTHGLSCRQBESIGIDFYSAMPOHGTYHIGMCYARXAFGReturn on equity →Price / book →
A bank or insurer earning more on its equity usually trades at a higher multiple of book; points far above the trend are priced for more. American Financial is the large dot.

Capital: ROE delivered against the ROE the price implies

10%20%30%10%20%30%ERIERNRIAGEGAIZ000810ADMTHGLMKLSCRQBESIGISAMPOHGTYMTGHIGMCYARXAFGROE delivered →ROE the price implies →
Above the diagonal = the price asks for a higher return on equity than the business earns today. American Financial is the large dot.

American Financial competitors and peer comparison

Head to head with its named competitors (AFG vs WRB vs CINF vs TRV)
CompanyMarket cap6M returnRevenue growthROEPrice / bookImplied ROE
American Financial AFG$13.1B+15%+2%22%2.77×16.1%
W. R. Berkley WRB$28.6B+14%+1%19%2.97×13.6%
Cincinnati Financial CINF$29.0B+13%+10%17%1.79×11.1%
Travelers Companies (The) TRV$80.3B+28%+1%28%2.77×14.4%

How American Financial compares with its peers

Peer set: Industry: the same industry and sector in any market, nearest in size. This is the same default set the interactive Competitor Analysis opens with.

American Financial against its 20 peers (data as of 18 Nov 2026)
MeasureAFGPeer medianRank in peer set
1-month return+5.8%+3.5%6th highest of 21
6-month return+15.3%+13.5%9th highest of 21
Return on equity21.6%14.4%6th highest of 21
Price / book2.77×2.02×7th most expensive of 21
Trailing P/E12.9×13.8×10th cheapest of 20
ROE the price implies16.1%11.3%5th most demanding of 21
ROE delivered21.6%14.3%6th highest of 21
Bond spread112 bp114 bp7th tightest of 13

Peer table

Peer set: Industry: the same industry and sector in any market, nearest in size
CompanyMarketMarket cap6M returnRevenue growthROEPrice / bookImplied ROEDelivered ROE
American Financial AFGUnited States$13.1B+15%+2%22%2.77×16.1%21.6%
Erie Indemnity ERIEUnited States$12.9B+24%+2%24%5.04×21.0%23.7%
RenaissanceRe RNRUnited States$14.0B+14%-21%13%1.34×7.8%13.4%
Insurance Australia IAG.AXAustralia$14.2B+17%+9%14%2.91×13.3%14.0%
Everest EGUnited States$15.6B+18%-9%13%1.10×6.9%12.8%
Assurant AIZUnited States$15.7B+25%+9%18%2.62×15.2%18.3%
SamsungF&MIns 000810.KSSouth Korea$15.7B+1%+6%8%0.72×4.9%8.3%
Admiral ADM.LUnited Kingdom$15.7B+13%0%46%8.01×34.6%45.6%
Hanover Insurance THGUnited States$8.42B+26%+5%22%2.45×11.7%21.8%
Loews LUnited States$22.2B+1%+3%8%1.22×8.5%8.1%
Markel MKLUnited States$23.7B+4%-1%10%1.28×9.5%9.6%
Scor SCR.PAFrance$6.88B+10%-4%19%1.45×10.0%18.8%
QBE Insurance QBE.AXAustralia$26.3B+15%+3%19%2.33×11.2%19.1%
Selective Insurance SIGIUnited States$6.12B+16%+4%15%1.88×9.7%14.7%
Definity Financial DFY.TOCanada$6.08B+4%+37%6%2.08×7.8%5.9%
Sampo SAMPO.HEFinland$28.2B+5%+2%16%3.61×11.4%16.5%
Hagerty HGTYUnited States$5.57B+47%+1%5%7.60×50.3%4.6%
MGIC Investment MTGUnited States$5.37B+2%-2%14%1.12×8.9%13.8%
Hartford (The) HIGUnited States$36.4B-1%+4%23%1.97×11.8%22.7%
Mercury General MCYUnited States$4.64B-19%+5%26%1.65×14.2%25.5%
Accelerant ARXUnited States$4.17B+19%+55%9%5.91×24.1%8.6%

American Financial bonds and credit

American Financial has 3 bonds outstanding with $1.17B face value. The agencies rate it BBB+; its bonds trade like BBB. Weighted yield 6.14%, a spread of 112 bp over government bonds.

Every bond, yield and spread in the cockpit →

Questions

Who are American Financial's main competitors?
Named competitors: W. R. Berkley (WRB), Cincinnati Financial (CINF), Travelers Companies (TRV). The cockpit's measured peer set (industry) also includes Erie Indemnity (ERIE), RenaissanceRe (RNR), Insurance Australia (IAG.AX), Everest (EG), Assurant (AIZ), SamsungF&MIns (000810.KS).
Is American Financial expensive compared with its peers?
On price / book it trades at 2.77× against a peer median of 2.02×, 7th most expensive of 21 in its peer set. The share price implies a return on equity of about 16.1%; American Financial delivers 21.6%, so the price asks less than the business earns today.
How has American Financial stock performed?
Over six months to 18 Nov 2026 the shares returned +15.3% against +13.5% for the median peer; over one year +13.7%.

How these numbers are made. Returns are close-to-close in local currency. Revenue growth and margins are trailing twelve months. Req g is the revenue growth that today's enterprise value requires for seven years at the company's own cost of capital; Delivered g is what it actually grew; the gap is the hurdle (honest precision about ±8 points, so read the ranking more than the decimal). No fair values, price targets or analyst ratings are shown, by design. Method and validation.